March 17, 2022
Thank you to Sen. Mark Kelly, D-Ariz., for voting yes on the Women’s Health Protection Act (HR3755) in the Senate on Feb. 28. The Senate voted on the bill that had passed out of the House, but unfortunately it did not reach enough votes to overcome the filibuster. The Senate Republican filibuster has now killed a woman’s right to choose, voting rights and Democrat-supported bills on child care, child tax credit, climate change and lower prescription drug costs.
The WHPA was drafted to codify the Roe v. Wade decision of the Supreme Court, now under assault. Roe v. Wade gave women the right to a safe abortion prior to the viability of the fetus (24 weeks.) The WHPA prohibits states from limiting a woman’s right to choose, and it prohibits calling for long wait times or additional unnecessary medical procedures. It does not call for U.S. government payment of abortions — that is decided by the Hyde Amendment, which prohibits the use of U.S. funds to pay for abortions. It also does not support late-term abortions, allowing for an abortion only at a time that threatens the life or health of the mother.
Ads now running on TV saying Sen. Kelly supports extreme late-term abortions and U.S.-funded abortions are just not true. These ads are funded by the Susan B. Anthony List, an avid anti-choice PAC, who decided to drag poor Susan B. Anthony, who did not have a position on abortion, into the fight. Women have had control over their bodies and their reproductive health since 1973. Polls show 71% of the population supports a woman’s right to choose. Women in Arizona are at particular risk with the Republican Arizona Legislature currently voting on SB1164, a bill that mirrors the draconian Mississippi law. Women are not going back.
Bobbi Seabolt, Casa Grande
August 26, 2021
In 1973 Congress declared Aug. 26 Women’s Equality Day to commemorate passage of the 19th Amendment, women’s right to vote, and as a symbol of the continued fight for equal rights for women. Women celebrate Aug. 26 and the fight continues.
When the Constitution was adopted, “We the People of the United States…” did not include women. Not until the 15th Amendment was ratified in 1870 granting freed slaves the right to vote were just male former slaves allowed to vote, and we know that the fight on voter suppression of people of color continues today.
At the 1848 women’s rights convention in Seneca Falls, the movement for the vote began its 72-year sojourn. It was first introduced in Congress in 1878 at the behest of Elizabeth Cady Stanton and Susan B. Anthony. Opposition to voting by women was widespread and the amendment did not see the light of day again until 1914. While the American women’s voting rights movement consisted mainly of civil disobedience, many of the women were arrested, imprisoned, beaten, hung by their thumbs, fed worms and force-fed. In May 1919, two-thirds of Congress voted in favor of the 19th Amendment; it was sent to the states for ratification, and ratified in August 1920. Then as now, those opposing women’s rights tried to stop it.
Today women are still fighting for the Equal Rights Amendment granting women full legal equality, formally added to the rights and protections of the Constitution. Numerous Supreme Court cases over the years have proven that women are not provided protections under the Constitution, despite the fact that protections have been provided to corporations.
It’s hard to believe that in the 21st century women still have to fight to correct their omission from the Constitution and be considered full citizens.
Bobbi Seabolt - ERA Task Force AZ
Maricopa County’s ballots have been boxed up, again, and moved somewhere (safe?) to make way for Arizona graduations. It is a good time to call it quits on a fiasco, a spectacle that has made Arizona the butt of jokes on the late night talk shows. If the Senate had really been serious about an audit of Maricopa ballots, they would have found the money and paid a reputable firm to do a real audit. This "fraudit" is nothing but a grift, a fundraising excuse and a source of speechless wonder for the rest of the country. Members of the Senate are in a place where they have the time and resources to do their own inquiries of issues with the ballots, and every one of the persons involved in this election in Arizona told them that there was no fraud. Yesterday the Maricopa County recorder, the sheriff and the Board of Supervisors (most of them Republicans) stated there was no fraud and it was time to call this circus “done.”
Senate members have reported that they are embarrassed by this ridiculous process. The voters of Arizona rely on their elected officials to tell them the truth. The Senate failed the voters because they knew there were no issues with the 2020 election, yet they allowed the “Big Lie” to perpetuate this assault on our democracy. The “Big Lie,” started before the election, was America’s first challenge to the peaceful transfer of power. If this "fraudit" continues, the voters can be expected to ask if all of the down-ballot officials really won their election, especially after they have done their best to embarrass Arizonans, and pass bills making it harder for them to vote next time.
Arizona voters, your Arizona Senate needs you to help them get out of this huge fiasco they have created for themselves and you. You must call or email them immediately and tell them to give up the “audit" and stop making it hard for us all to vote.
The "big lie," a lie so big it must be true, the lie that our last election was not fair and secure, has captured your Arizona Senate. Now that the rest of the world, most of America, most of Arizona and anyone who does not exclusively watch Fox News, knows Trump’s big lie for what it was, the Arizona Senate is left for all the world to see, as to have fallen for the con. It’s hard to admit you have been conned, especially when everyone is watching. Sidney Powell, when sued for billions by Dominion voting machines, admitted the con by having her lawyers say: ‘no reasonable person would take her claims about Dominion seriously.’ Maybe a lawsuit will get their attention? Katie Hobbs, secretary of state, please continue to do what you can to protect the sanctity of the private ballot.
The Senate contracted Cyber Ninjas and their subcontractors, firms with no audit experience and clear ties to the insurrection and Trump, to recount, for the fourth time, the millions of ballots, by hand, a job that would take thousands of people weeks to do while completely undoing the sanctity of the secret ballot. The spectacle, and total invasion of privacy of the contracted Cyber Ninjas mucking about in the 28 tons of sacred paper ballots and knocking on doors asking voters if and how they voted, is an embarrassment to Arizona, and everyone is watching. Pay attention, Arizona, democracy is still on the line. When you go looking for your PEVL in November, it will be too late.
Glad to see that the Dispatch editorial on March 4 supports voting, and that “states that run elections responsibly, including Arizona, should be allowed to continue.” Thus, shouldn’t all the states be using the same rules? There is no doubt that the 2020 Arizona election was run responsibly, much of it by mail, as usual. Numerous audits were conducted in Arizona with no flaws found, numerous (60-plus nationwide) court cases found no fraud, and the former administration’s own cybersecurity chief declared the election fraud free. Once all of the paper ballots, their envelopes, the software, the voting machines for Maricopa County have been delivered to the Arizona Senate (defying state law to secure these items) and they have their opportunity to diddle around with the info, there will be another audit result, this one of questionable value. Our nation’s problem is not election integrity, which for years has had no documented fraud, but the “big lie,” started by the former president, before the election, fed and refed to the public through Fox and other media, and amplified by every elected Republican, notably Republicans Gosar, Lesko, Biggs and Finchem, that have now brought our nation to the Jan. 6 insurrection.
The U.S. House of Representatives has just passed HR 1, which would strengthen voting rights, overhaul campaign finance laws, prevent gerrymandering, create automatic voter registration and expand access to early and mail-in voting. Arizona led the nation with the much-loved permanent early voting list and already allows voter registration at the MVA. Arizonans, four years ago, before the “big lie,” were you opposed to the PEVL? HR1 would set a national standard for elections, and isn’t that what it is all about — as the Dispatch says: “every ballot will count — -and count equally.”
It’s way past time to put Trump’s “big lie” to rest. Trump told us before the election that if he did not win, he would claim it was “‘rigged,” and he did just that. He spread his “big lie,” an attempted coup, an override of a free and fair election, between election day and Jan. 6, and Republican leaders, who have been complicit in all of Trump’s lies, supported the sore loser Trump and his last “big lie.” Congressmen Paul Gosar, R-CD4, Andy Biggs, R-CD5, and Mo Brooks, R-Ala., according to planner Ali Akbar Alexander, were instrumental in organizing the Jan. 6 insurrection. Arizona Congresspersons Lesko, R-CD8, Gosar and Biggs voted, after the insurrection, to disenfranchise their own voters and not accept certification of the vote of their very own state, an election they had just won.
Mark Finchem, R-LD11, attended the insurrection, tweeting his support for the deadly mob. Sen. Karen Fann, R-LD1, and Sen. Warren Petersen, R-LD12, have subpoenaed “all original paper ballots” in Maricopa County, as well as county voting equipment and software. Maricopa ballots have already been counted, audited and recounted numerous times, and the details are on the Maricopa County Election Facts web page for anyone willing to read it. And now Republicans are challenging the election of Kelli Ward, Miss “Stop the Steal,” to be chair of their party. Kelli does not appear to be supportive of any recount on her election. Trump’s approach to his loss was to utilize the tools dictators have used throughout history. Trump incited the riot on live TV, Gosar led the fight on the House floor to disenfranchise Arizona voters, with Biggs and Lesko voting with him. Finchem got himself to Washington, D.C., and tweeted support of the insurrection. All of these Republicans are undermining our democracy.
Residents of Pinal County — you could be next. If you live in Maricopa County you are out of luck, though most of the Maricopa Board of Supervisors are fighting for you. Republican Sen. Eddie Farnsworth and Republican Senate President Karen Fann issued a sweeping subpoena seeking a raft of data and copies of all mail-in ballots from the Nov. 3 election. The Senate Judiciary Committee issued a subpoena per the Dec. 19 Dispatch: “to collect all images of all mail ballots, including lists of voters, their addresses, how and where they voted and much more.” They also want (for maybe the fourth time?) “a full forensic audit of ballot tabulation machines and software.” All eight lawsuits in Arizona challenging election and voter fraud in Arizona have failed.
Our votes are sacred, private information. Wives don’t tell their husbands, children don’t tell their parents, but now Eddie and Karen are going to know how you voted. Maybe if more people on 12th Street voted for Biden, they won’t get their potholes fixed. Maybe when you apply for a job, they’ll look at your voting record. In what universe does this invasion of privacy, violation of constitutional rights, destruction of everything American, and insult to our flag belong? Who would vote for these people? Now? So, this is conservative values? If the Trump cult succeeds with this subpoena, all voters in Arizona are threatened, democracy is endangered and voting is suppressed.
Casa Grande, you have lit up your houses for the holiday bringing cheer to us all! Surely, you also then believe in good will to men — and women. Can we not then agree that the peaceful exchange of power is an American tradition? Can we not all agree that our votes are sacred, and ours, not belonging to the Trump cult?
The Dispatch just reported that hate crimes are up. (Nov. 17). I don’t remember, before 2016, Americans plotting to kidnap a governor, demonstrating and threatening Arizonans in charge of elections, marching through Charlottesville with tiki torches or taking long guns to our legislatures. All of this hate and division has come to America since Donald Trump. I guess all of us had the relative that we avoided at the holidays, but this year, families are divided, with Donald Trump at every holiday table and every Zoom meeting. Many of us thought that the lies, the hate spewing, the danger, would stop with this election, declared safe and secure by Trump’s own cybersecurity chief, but instead America is being humiliated by the spoiled child in the White House who won’t accept the results of an election. All of the world, friend and foe, are watching. Vladimir Putin, who gleefully watched his efforts succeed in the 2016 election, is again toasting the continued success of his efforts as even in defeat, Trump spews massive disinformation and “alternative facts” undermining America’s democracy.
Our President-elect Joe Biden has clearly stated that he is going to be a president for all of America. He has won this election with more votes than the current president garnered in 2016. I think everyone in America is exhausted from COVID and the division and chaos that Trump has injected into every family, every day and every life. If we are to be united again, we are all going to have to work at it. We are all going to have to spend some time verifying our "truths." Please remember that Democrats love the Constitution, democracy, the flag and law and order, and to say they don’t is just another lie meant to divide us.
The Dispatch’s photo on Page 3A of the Oct. 15 issue speaks volumes to Arizonans on the year 2020 and the four years we have endured under the Trump administration. On view are three sections of a hundreds-year-old saguaro, cut to make way for the border wall looming in the background, the wall built with illegal funds stolen from military budgets and in violation of environmental regulations. On Indigenous Peoples Day, members of the Tohono O’odham Nation, our neighbors, came to Organ Pipe National Monument to protest the building of that wall on their sacred land.
We can vote for leaders that respect the indigenous peoples that cared for Arizona before us, for those that respect science and for those that love our planet. We can’t fix what is wrong with our country with platitudes such as flag, Constitution and democracy, words quick to come from Trump supporters. We vote not for the flag, but what the flag represents. We vote, not for "the Constitution" or parts of it cherry-picked out that suit our interests, but we vote for all of the Constitution and all of the concepts it embraces.
We can vote for Joe Biden and Kamala Harris. We can vote for Mark Kelly and a change to our Senate that has left 300-400 bills in Mitch’s drawer, at least one of which is badly needed pandemic relief. We can vote for our congressman from CD1, Tom O'Halleran, who continues to do his job and send bills for Arizona to the Senate. We can support all the Democrats on our ballot, including those representing us in the state, Barbara McGuire and Sharon Girard in LD8 and JoAnna Mendoza and Dr. Felipe Perez in LD11. Your vote has never been more important, make your plan now to get it done.
Here it is just days after 9/11, and those of us who were old enough at the time to process the event know where we were that awful day. In the days after, we truly became the United States of America. We came together to grieve together, to reach out to every family member and make sure they were all right, to reach out to neighbor and our cousin's neighbor to tell them we were with them. Nineteen years ago, no one would have believed that a Republican-led Senate would for years stall health care coverage for the first responder heroes of that day, and no one would have believed this week’s news that the Trump administration secretly withheld $4 million from this fund.
Now in 2020, we face an enemy 64 times more deadly than 9/11 — the coronavirus. Yet, with 194,000 already lost, we have not come together to fight this virus, we are not wearing masks as our opportunity to protect our family, our friends and our country. The president of this country has worn a mask maybe three to four times and has just concluded an indoor rally with maskless attendees in Phoenix, a "superspreader" event. He just called our veterans “suckers” and “losers.” The Trump-installed communications director at the CDC, with not a scrap of scientific background, is editing the MMWR, the weekly scientific data communication of the CDC to health professionals.
We can do better than this, America, because we did. In September 2001 we came together as a nation. We can do it again, but not with this president, not with this Senate that won’t even vote on bills. Give our country a chance and vote for change, vote for Democrats.
There is a lot of news in Arizona — our COVID cases are still increasing, and people are dying. One thing that is not news: Martha McSally is still telling everyone that she is going to protect preexisting conditions. Frankly, I’m worried about the young lady from Martha’s newest ad. She has a preexisting condition and is sure that Martha is going to protect her. When in the House, Martha voted every time to repeal the Affordable Care Act, which does protect preexisting conditions. Since its inception in 2010, according to Newsweek, the Republicans have voted 70 times to try and repeal Obamacare. Since she got to the Senate, Martha has continued her attack on those with health issues. She has voted for and supports the Protect Act — a Republican six-page bill designed to replace the well-thought-out 2,500-page-plus Affordable Care Act. The Protect Act lets insurers charge whatever they want to those with preexisting conditions. In October 2017, Trump failed to pay the federal government subsidy to insurers that was promised in the Affordable Care Act, and on June 26, 2020, Trump’s Department of Justice filed a brief supporting Republican attorneys general to eliminate Obamacare, which would leave millions of Americans uninsured during a pandemic.
Health insurance is complicated, it was complicated before COVID and now is far more complicated. Millions are now unemployed, thus have no employer-based health insurance. Millions have or had COVID, thus have a preexisting condition. All hospitals, especially rural, face daunting financial issues. Each hospital COVID case costs thousands of dollars. Arizona needs someone we can trust, like Mark Kelly, to lead us through this pandemic and the chaos it has brought to us and our health care system.
Does anyone think, now that we are three to four months into a global pandemic, that the for-profit system of health coverage that we have in this country will be able to continue as before?
If you are over 65 and thus on Medicare, our country's best health care coverage, please refrain from yelling “socialism," and thank God and country every night for your Medicare card and your Social Security payment. The hot debate in the early primaries (was that only a few months ago?) between "health care for all" and expanded Obamacare is now a new story. Since passage of Obamacare, Republicans have voted repeatedly to "repeal and replace," but Republicans have never offered any plan for replacement. Despite her ads, Martha McSally, in the House and in the Senate, voted countless times to repeal Obamacare with its preexisting conditions protections, and as we write this, Donald Trump’s Justice Department is in court trying to invalidate Obamacare. He has already issued several Executive Orders to unfund and undermine it.
For now, those who are without health care can visit Sun Life, a federally qualified community health center, and get help to apply for health care. One should call first for an appointment and be prepared to bring in financial documents. Call 520-381-0394 and ask for an enrollment specialist. The $600 one is now getting from the federal government does not count into your income for AHCCCS eligibility. One can first apply for Obamacare, which generally needs to be done within 60 days of layoff. For more information visit www.healthearizonaplus.gov (note the e) or healthcare.gov. Health care coverage, especially now, is an investment in yourself and your family.
Michael Flynn is in the news again (Justice for Mike Flynn, May 2). Michael Flynn has pleaded guilty to lying to the FBI on two occasions and he has stated in open court to Judge Emmet Sullivan that he was indeed guilty. There is no doubt about his guilt. The FBI has an intercept — a tape of the conversation between Flynn and Kislyak — where Flynn told the Russian ambassador to ignore the sanctions that President Obama placed on Russia for interfering in the 2016 election because the Trump administration would deal with it differently. So, yes, he told our adversary Russia to ignore sanctions from our country’s president, and yes, he lied to the FBI when they asked him about it. Recently, notes from FBI agents preparing for the Flynn questioning have been quoted but not in their entirety. There were hundreds of pages of emails and notes among the FBI personnel discussing the Flynn interview turned over to Flynn’s new lawyer, the Fox News favorite, Sidney Powell. In addition, Michael Flynn and his son Michael Flynn Jr. were both criminally liable for not registering as foreign agents for their involvement in a plot to kidnap cleric Fethullah Gulen for the Turkish government for which they were to be paid millions of dollars.
If it was up to me, I would have charged Flynn with treason. Flynn was a lieutenant general in the U.S. Army who went behind the back of the sitting U.S. president and called our adversary Russia, and plotted with a foreign government to kidnap a cleric; he should have known better. Before Donald Trump there was an America, and a Republican Party, that saw Russia as an adversary, who respected the rule of law.
Arizona voters, you are in luck! While the rest of the country wrestles with the obvious need for mail-in voting during this pandemic, Arizonans are fortunate — you already have a law on the books called Permanent Early Voting List, or PEVL. Arizona has two types of mail-in voting — the Early Ballot is a request for a mail-in ballot for one or two elections (other states call this an Absentee Ballot) and the PEVL. A voter can disenroll from PEVL with a signed application, so PEVL is the easier choice. Right now, reports are that 80% of you have already signed up for PEVL. Now is the time, when many of us have time on our hands, for the other 20% of voters to apply for PEVL!
There are two ways to apply. You can reregister to vote and check the box for PEVL at ADOT, accessed through ServiceArizona.com. (This site is closed until April 21 for an update.) This is a good choice if you have recently moved or changed your name. Alternatively, you can go online to the Pinal County Recorder’s Office at https://www.pinalcountyaz.gov/Vote/Pages/PermanentEarlyVotingRegistration.aspx for a one-page application. The application asks for your name, address, telephone number, date of birth and your signature. It’s important to take a minute to sign your name, because if it does not look like the same signature as the one on your ballot, they could throw your ballot out. If you don’t have access to the internet, call Pinal County 311 at 520-509-3555. Mail your application back to the address on the bottom of the page.
Republicans might be on to something. The only way today that Republicans and their current values can win an election is to suppress voting. It’s time for you to get that same good feeling you get when you go to the polls and vote — and sign up now to get a mail-in ballot.